Brother's pizza

Brother's Pizza in New Port Richey offers authentic Italian-style pizza, calzones, wings, and more. Enjoy dine-in, takeaway, or delivery in a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere. Call +1 727-400-3220 for delicious, love-infused comfort food today!

Welcome to Brother's pizza

Signature Dining Experience

Brother's pizza
Brother's pizza
Brother's pizza
Brother's pizza

Taste the heart of Italy right in New Port Richey at Brother's Pizza. Located at 6516 Massachusetts Ave, our cozy, family-run restaurant crafts authentic New York-style pizza with a focus on quality and love. We pride ourselves on a warm, welcoming atmosphere that makes every meal feel like a visit to grandma's kitchen. From the crispy crust to rich toppings, every slice delivers comfort and flavor.

Whether it’s a quick lunch, a family dinner, or solo craving, our menu offers a variety of traditional and gourmet options you’ll love. No delivery, but plenty of easy takeaway and dine-in options make us your neighborhood favorite. Join locals who appreciate fresh ingredients, hearty bites, and the community vibe that makes Brother’s Pizza more than just a place to eat—it's a local gathering spot.

Location & Contact

Address

6516 Massachusetts Ave, New Port Richey, FL 34653, United States

Phone

+1 727-400-3220

Social Media

About

Brother's pizza
Brother's pizza
Brother's pizza
Brother's pizza

Brother’s Pizza is a family-centered Italian-American restaurant that captures the essence of New York-style pizza here in Florida. Since opening, we've built a reputation for quality ingredients, generous toppings, and a genuine hospitality that makes every guest feel like part of our family. We specialize in making pizza with a crispy, flavorful crust, topped with fresh cheeses, meats, and vegetables. Our menu features a range of options including calzones, strombolis, wraps, and hot subs, all crafted with care. We don’t just serve food; we serve a piece of tradition, infused with love and respect for our community.

Our staff, led by Gabriel and his wife, aim to provide excellent service, quick turnaround, and a wholesome experience. Brother’s Pizza is a spot where families meet, friends connect, and locals gather for authentic flavors and a cozy vibe.

Work Hours

  • Sunday11 AM–9 PM
  • Monday11 AM–9 PM
  • TuesdayClosed
  • Wednesday11 AM–9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM–9 PM
  • Friday11 AM–9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM–9 PM

Brother's Pizza combines authentic Italian techniques with a friendly, neighborhood vibe. We serve a variety of pizzas, including classics, stuffed options, and gourmet creations like our Taco Pizza and Buffalo Chicken Pizza. Small plates and comfort food like garlic knots, wings, and hot subs round out our offerings. Our takeout and dine-in service are designed for your convenience, and our place is wheelchair accessible, ensuring everyone can enjoy a meal. We accept credit and debit cards, and our prices stay friendly at $10–$20, making quality pizza a consistent treat. Perfect for lunch or dinner, our location boasts free street parking and a welcoming atmosphere that invites you to relax and savor each bite.

Brother's pizza

Brother’s Pizza presents a welcoming street-front with a casual, cozy vibe. The exterior features classic signage and ample free parking that makes visiting easy. Inside, the atmosphere is laid-back, inviting families, kids, and solo diners alike. The decor reflects a rustic yet modern Italian family kitchen, with warm lighting and communal tables that foster community. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or enjoying a relaxed dinner, the vibe encourages friendly conversations and shared smiles. This is a neighborhood spot where the aroma of garlic knots and freshly baked pizza fills the air, welcoming you into a haven of comfort and good company.

Customer Reviews

I love Brother's Pizza. The pizza maker guy always greets you with a genuine caring smile. It feels wholesome. You know when you eat in grandma's kitchen and you ask her what's the secret ingredient then she says "Love." That's what this place is all about. I bet they put love into the food. Something about it just hits different from other pizza places.

L
Leslie J.

Small dine-in and carry-out Italian-American restaurant. Ordered a 14 inch pepperoni and garlic knots. Pizza was cooked to perfection and was hot and ready on the spot. The garlic knots are drizzled in oil and garlic parmesan. Heated up nicely the next day as well!

N
Noah B.

Had dinner last night and I had the chicken parmiginna with pasta. It was the best. Gabriel and wife were very pleasant and the service was the best. I would 100% recommend Brothers pizza for exclent food and price. John Mackenzie

J
John M.

I arrived here on a golf cart with My 2 large dogs. Pizza was ready. Dogs were tethered, so I could’ve walked in, but he walked it out to me. 12 blocks home, pizza was still hot and crispy! Even with 3 toppings. This is my go to place every time!

R
Robin K.

Ordered their specialty pizza and garlic hot wings for my staff today and we all enjoyed it. Very good food and the staff is great. We will be using this place as our pizza lunch spot. Kudos to management/ownership. Great stuff here. 👏

K
Kelly A.

I came here and asked the owner if he could live up to his review... and he certainly did. The dough is home made and results in a really nice crust. Our pizzas were baked perfectly. These are thin but not overly so. The sauce was good and cheese was at a great level. We ordered meat lovers and pepperoni. These toppings were great and not greasy. Our garlic knots and marinara were really good as well. Recommend you try this place. I am sure you will be pleased.

P
Phil